GF-3与Sentinel-1影像对山区小水体提取能力评估

    Performance evaluation of GF-3 and Sentinel-1 in extracting small water bodies in mountainous areas

    • 摘要: 为解决山区小水体监测中的实时跟踪难题,提高监测精度,评估GF-3和Sentinel-1雷达卫星影像的水体提取能力。在香溪河流域内选取多个水库,采用局部阈值法对两种雷达影像进行水体提取,并将结果与Sentinel-2 MSI影像使用归一化差分水体指数(NDWI)的提取结果进行比较,再通过精度指标进行定量分析。结果表明: GF-3在捕捉水体变化方面具有优势,召回率最高可达0.952,但在复杂地形下容易受到噪声影响而产生错误提取; 相较之下,Sentinel-1展现出更好的精确度和一致性,精准率最高达到0.913,交并比(IoU)最高为0.830;在淹没频率分析中,GF-3对比Sentinel-1展现了更丰富的时空变化特征。研究成果可为云雨天气条件下水库群水体提取和水资源管理提供科学依据。

       

      Abstract: To address the challenge of real-time monitoring of small water bodies in mountainous areas and to improve monitoring accuracy, we evaluated the water body extraction capabilities of GF-3 and Sentinel-1 radar satellite imagery.A local threshold method was applied to extract water body from radar images in multiple reservoirs in the Xiangxi River Basin.The extraction results were compared with those obtained from Sentinel-2 MSI imagery using the normalized difference water index (NDWI), followed by a quantitative analysis based on accuracy metrics.The results indicate that GF-3 has advantages in capturing water body changes, achieving a maximum recall rate of 0.952, but it is tend to be influenced by noise-induced errors in complex terrain.In contrast, Sentinel-1 demonstrates better accuracy and consistency, with a maximum precision rate of 0.913 and a maximum Intersection over Union (IoU) of 0.830.In the analysis of inundation frequency, GF-3 reveals richer spatiotemporal variations compared to Sentinel-1.The findings provide a scientific basis for the extraction of reservoir water body and water resource management under cloudy and rainy weather conditions.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回